I have friends that are having trouble. I hate this because I really love both of them. They have asked me for my advice and frankly I have some I would like to tell them. I think this might be a bad decision. What do you think?
Dear Both are my Friends, It sounds like you’re caught between wanting to help your friends and the potential consequences of getting involved in their personal issues. It’s tough when you care deeply about both of them, and I bet it’s tearing you up inside. But here’s the thing: offering advice to friends in conflict is like walking into a minefield— things can blow up.
You might feel like you have the wisdom to help them sort things out. Maybe you've seen both sides of their argument and feel like you could be the bridge that brings them back together. It’s tempting, right? Especially if you feel like you're in the middle, watching people you care about struggle, and wanting to make it all better.
But—here’s the kicker— giving advice when both friends are in conflict will backfire. Even if you have the best intentions, one or both of them will misinterpret your input. It's easy for people to hear what they want to hear instead of what you're actually saying. You risk being blamed if your advice doesn’t work out the way they hoped or if things go south. If they’re really heated, they might not be ready for advice at all—they might just want to vent.
The real danger is in picking sides, even if you think you're not. You might share your perspective, and all of a sudden, one of them thinks you're against them. Then you’ve gone from a loving neutral party to part of the problem. Friends, especially during a heated moment, can get defensive or even accuse you of favoring the other person. Worse, it could damage your relationship with one or both of them in the long run.
I’ve been there, too. I remember a time when two dear friends of mine were at each other’s throats, and I thought I could play peacekeeper. Guess what? It didn’t work. One of them felt betrayed, the other heard something completely different than what I said, and in the end, I felt caught in a mess I never wanted to be in. I should have just let them work it out on their own.
Sometimes people don’t need advice; they just need someone to listen. Be a sounding board, and let them express their frustrations without jumping in with solutions. This allows them to feel heard and validated, which is often more valuable than offering a “fix.”
If they ask for your advice directly, answer with questions like, “How do you feel about what’s going on?” or “What do you think would make the situation better?” This helps them come to their own conclusions without you having to pick a side. Plus, their own solutions are usually the ones they’ll be most committed to following.
If it feels like they’re dragging you into their conflict, don’t be afraid to say, “I love you both, but I can’t be the mediator here. I’m happy to support you, but this is something you two need to work out.” It’s important to protect your own peace of mind while they figure things out.
If they’re really struggling, you should suggest that they talk to someone who is trained to handle conflicts— like a counselor or mediator. That way, they get professional advice without putting you in the middle.
If you absolutely must give advice, be prepared for the possibility that it might not be received well. If you know their relationship dynamics better than anyone else and feel like your insight could genuinely help without causing harm, then tread carefully. Start by asking if they actually want advice, and then deliver it with as much kindness and neutrality as possible. Emphasize that you’re not picking sides, but rather trying to support both of them in moving forward.
In my experience, though, people usually find their way through tough spots like this, even if it feels like the world is ending for them. It’s hard to see friends struggle, but sometimes the best thing we can do is stand by and offer unconditional love—not solutions.
So, what do I think? I think you should trust your gut but keep in mind that usually staying out of it is the best decision for everyone. There’s a good chance that whatever advice you have could be useful, but there’s an even bigger chance that offering it could put you in the line of fire. The safest play? Be a loving friend, offer an ear to listen, and let them work through their issues themselves.
Love,
Aunt B
If you would like to send Aunt B a question please email your question to news@ forneymessenger. com.
- Log in or Subscribe to post comments.